0:00:00.501,0:00:02.508
CATHY LEWIS: How do you answer skeptics?

0:00:02.508,0:00:04.111
Because I'm sure that they still come to you

0:00:04.111,0:00:06.322
and say "I'm sorry, I [inaudible] it."

0:00:06.322,0:00:07.523
How do you answer that?

0:00:07.523,0:00:10.423
ADM. DAVID TITLEY: I mean, what I do is

0:00:10.423,0:00:14.072
I kind of go through in a, thank God, more abbreviated version

0:00:14.072,0:00:16.780
than what I did this evening,

0:00:16.780,0:00:19.043
but basically just try to walk through the physics

0:00:19.043,0:00:22.779
because-- at a very basic, conceptual level,

0:00:22.779,0:00:25.571
no equations, no nothing like that.

0:00:25.571,0:00:28.526
Because we know the climate's changing.

0:00:28.526,0:00:31.033
I mean, there's just too much data for us.

0:00:31.033,0:00:34.830
And again, I kind of go back to my time on that ship that I showed you,

0:00:34.830,0:00:36.133
USS Farragut.

0:00:36.133,0:00:38.322
I was privileged to be the navigator,

0:00:38.322,0:00:39.743
which is a really, really cool job,

0:00:39.743,0:00:41.535
because you're the only junior officer that can

0:00:41.535,0:00:42.986
tell the captain where to go.

0:00:42.986,0:00:44.824
So that's actually kind of fun.

0:00:44.824,0:00:48.033
But one of the things you learn as a navigator--

0:00:48.033,0:00:48.953
if you don't learn it,

0:00:48.953,0:00:51.200
you're probably not going to be one very long--

0:00:51.200,0:00:55.921
is you never trust any one individual data point.

0:00:55.921,0:00:58.629
So, you know, I kind of look at climate change like that.

0:00:58.629,0:01:00.467
If it was just the Arctic,

0:01:00.467,0:01:03.164
but all the glaciers were like, you know, being the same

0:01:03.164,0:01:05.855
or coming down, and there were no temperature changes,

0:01:05.855,0:01:10.495
there was no acidification change in the ocean, well, OK,

0:01:10.495,0:01:12.033
we've probably got to look at something else.

0:01:12.033,0:01:14.188
But when you look at all the data,

0:01:14.188,0:01:16.311
it all lines up with a consistent picture.

0:01:16.311,0:01:17.682
You can actually model it,

0:01:17.682,0:01:19.821
you take out the carbon dioxide, you don't get the right answer;

0:01:19.821,0:01:23.698
you put in the CO2, you get the right answer.

0:01:23.698,0:01:25.682
So you can kind of go through that

0:01:25.682,0:01:27.824
and I just gave one example of,

0:01:27.824,0:01:30.083
you know, when skeptics have a question about,

0:01:30.083,0:01:31.167
what's a trace gas.

0:01:31.167,0:01:32.761
And I hear that all the time.

0:01:32.761,0:01:34.495
Well, hey, alcohol's a trace,

0:01:34.495,0:01:36.104
but we sure hear about that.

0:01:36.104,0:01:38.090
So just because it's a trace,

0:01:38.090,0:01:39.161
it's interesting,

0:01:39.161,0:01:42.792
but it doesn't mean that it cannot be effective.

0:01:42.792,0:01:45.300
So what I've found is

0:01:45.300,0:01:49.904
that people who really, really, really believe it's all a vast conspiracy theory,

0:01:49.904,0:01:51.609
there's not much you can say.

0:01:51.609,0:01:52.578
But I would say--

0:01:52.578,0:01:56.428
and again, could I just get a show of hands of whose been in the military?

0:01:56.428,0:01:57.864
OK, so a bunch.

0:01:57.864,0:02:01.260
So you guys and gals will probably sort of understand this.

0:02:01.260,0:02:02.854
You know in the military we have some

0:02:02.854,0:02:05.915
very, very, very sensitive programs

0:02:05.915,0:02:08.188
and you read people in,

0:02:08.188,0:02:11.448
make them take polygraphs half the time,

0:02:11.448,0:02:15.575
you are told to never, ever, ever talk about them.

0:02:15.575,0:02:17.509
If you do, we will humiliate you,

0:02:17.509,0:02:18.684
we will take you to jail,

0:02:18.684,0:02:20.669
we will take away your job.

0:02:20.669,0:02:24.118
Even then, it's pretty hard to keep a secret. Right?

0:02:24.118,0:02:26.024
It's pretty hard to keep a secret.

0:02:26.024,0:02:27.513
So what I sometimes want to know,

0:02:27.513,0:02:29.179
when I hear these conspiracy theories

0:02:29.179,0:02:33.443
is how do you get about 3,000 academics across the world

0:02:33.443,0:02:34.749
who like to talk,

0:02:34.749,0:02:36.604
who (oh, by the way) if they could really disprove this,

0:02:36.604,0:02:39.660
there's probably a Nobel Prize in it for somebody.

0:02:39.660,0:02:40.496
You know, how--how--

0:02:40.496,0:02:42.691
do they all like sign an oath or something

0:02:42.691,0:02:43.997
that they were all going to say this?

0:02:43.997,0:02:45.747
I mean, we've got a hard time in the Navy

0:02:45.747,0:02:48.438
to try and keep some.

0:02:48.438,0:02:49.509
It's a challenge.

0:02:49.509,0:02:52.176
So are you telling me a bunch of academics

0:02:52.176,0:02:54.215
who like to talk are going to...you know...

0:02:54.215,0:02:55.935
it just doesn't pass the sense.

0:02:55.935,0:02:59.096
You know, there are some people you just aren't going to convince.

0:02:59.096,0:03:02.753
But then, you know, that's OK.

0:03:02.753,0:03:04.143
LEWIS: So I guess the issue would be then,

0:03:04.143,0:03:05.981
and I think you were talking about this a little earlier,

0:03:05.981,0:03:08.689
there will be a percentage of people who will believe you no matter what,

0:03:08.689,0:03:11.998
a percentage of people who will disbelieve you no matter what,

0:03:11.998,0:03:15.109
so the battle is for what's in the middle.

0:03:15.109,0:03:16.711
ADM. TITLEY: [inaudible] of the New York Times

0:03:16.711,0:03:19.285
really writes about this, the so-called six people.

0:03:19.285,0:03:21.378
And yeah, people on either end are there,

0:03:21.378,0:03:24.131
and the people in the middle slosh around,

0:03:24.131,0:03:26.772
and they'll, you know, I really think,

0:03:26.772,0:03:29.446
I'm pretty optimistic, people listen to reason.

0:03:29.446,0:03:31.251
If you can make a well-reasoned case,

0:03:31.251,0:03:34.895
you know, giving somebody just a spreadsheet or whatever

0:03:34.895,0:03:36.738
or one picture of a [inaudible]

0:03:36.738,0:03:38.514
probably doesn't do much, but

0:03:38.514,0:03:40.076
you know, it's sort of building the first principles.

0:03:40.076,0:03:43.765
I think, you look at all the data.

0:03:43.765,0:03:46.926
As I said, I didn't start off really believing much of this.

0:03:46.926,0:03:47.797
but as you look at it,

0:03:47.797,0:03:50.165
I mean, you've got to kind of come to a conclusion.

0:03:50.165,0:03:51.523
So it's what Churchill said,

0:03:51.523,0:03:52.677
can you, when you see the truth,

0:03:52.677,9:59:59.000
can you, can you kind of change your own--